© Harise Stein, MD 2002-2006
  Women’s Center for Mind-Body Health

Review of Preoperative Surgical Tapes

  Home
   
  New
   
  The Center
   
  M-B Health
   
  Resources
     Surgery prep
   Tape Review
     Hospitals
     Mindfulness
     Links
     Books, tapes
   
  Research

See Preparing for Surgery to understand the rationale for using a preop tape.

Contact Dr. Stein if you have a preop tape you’d like reviewed.

 

What category of tape should I chose?

How often should I listen?

What design parameters should I consider?

Table comparison of commercial tapes

Detailed information on commercial tapes

Make your own tape

What category of tape should I chose?
The first decision you need to make is what your source will be.

Tape source

Pros

Cons

Sum up

Make your own

-Inexpensive

-Own powerful    images

-Private

-Possibly therapeutic

to do

-Can involve family

-Lack of expertise

   --miss meaningful        images

   --unhelpful images

   --technical difficulties

-Lack of time, focus      

-Who will record?  (Will

you or loved one sound scared?)               

A challenge, but

very rewarding for someone to whom

the act is

meaningful.

Commercial

-Usually

modest cost

-Highly researched

-Convenient

-Track record

-Can give as gift

-No perfect tape setup

for everyone

-Your own images might be more powerful

 

In general the most

practical option, and can be

very effective.

Custom by

medical

professional

-Combines best of both—

your images plus

professional expertise

 

-Cost

-Time to find someone,

make appt. ,  be seen and have tape made.

Very helpful to those who have

the time and

money, or need extra support

around surgical

issues

. 
[Top]

How often should I listen?
No formal studies have been done to determine what constitutes “enough”.  Each of the commercial tapes has different suggestions for how often and for how many days to listen.  Earlier studies that were done before the more common use of tapes, showed that even providing relaxation or making suggestions just before surgery showed positive results.  So anything is better than nothing.  Twice a day for three days prior to surgery is a reasonable minimum, with more days or even weeks ahead being desirable if it is possible.  Most tapes last about 20 minutes.  One tape (Huddleston) insists on patients staying awake while they listen, but others believe if you happen to fall asleep while you are listening, you will still benefit.  Yet another tape, Hemi-sync, wants you to fall asleep after you listen.   Listening first thing in the morning and just before sleep has been suggested, as one method of helping you to listen when you are in a more relaxed state.  In general, the logistics of when, where and how often to listen are less important than just doing it.

[Top]


What design parameters should I consider?

If you decide to buy a commercial tape or make your own, you then need to consider how you feel about the following options:

Voice Male or female?
Background Nothing, music, nature sounds?  What would help you become the most relaxed?
Format There are three time periods to consider: preop, intraop (while you are having surgery) and postop.  For each time period, you can choose either talking or background sounds.  For the preop period, studies show that preop medical suggestions work.  Intraop, suggestions don't seem to work as consistently well, however it is important to listen to something intraop to help mask possible operating room sounds heard while under anesthesia. (See Research-Hospital-Anesthesia.)  Postop is also a very important period, since your body is healing, and you might have stresses of a difficult diagnosis, or unexpected tubes to deal with.  You can alternate postop suggestions with just listening to background sounds, like music or the ocean, to help relieve anxiety.
Medical suggestions Specific suggestions, such as to increase bowel function, are effective.  How many of these do you want to hear?  Or would you rather avoid the whole issue of surgery and just have a generic relaxation tape?
Tone The words chosen in the practice of imagery are generally described as more directive or more permissive.  Directive language, such as “You will …”, coupled with the use of repetition and counting down to deepen a relaxed state, are typical hypnotherapy techniques.  A few of the tapes below have a more hypnotic slant as opposed to simple imagery.  Some people find directive language irritating, while it doesn’t bother others at all.
Friends &
Family
Does invoking the images of friends and family supporting you help you feel encouraged, or are there issues that cause this to be painful?
Spirituality Do you feel comforted by the mention of spirituality or religious entities, or does this make you ill at ease?

[Top]


Table comparison of commercial tapes
The following is a table outlining the parameters of several commercial preop tapes, listed in alphabetical order.  There is no one “best” tape.  Each has something to offer.  The best tape is the one that fits you the best.  And even though one or two parameters might be a little different than what you may have preferred, most people can adapt easily if the tape in general meets their needs. 
[Note: some childhood sexual abusers referred to their victim as their special girl, or that they were going to go to their special place.  Several of these tapes mention going to a special place.  If this is an issue for you, Hemi-sync and Huddleston don't use the word special, Naparstek and Neiman use it once, and Rodgers and Tusek three times.]

V = voice  

B = background

F = format

MS = medical suggestions (rated 0 - +++)

T = tone (P permissive, D directive)

FF = family and friends (rated 0 - +++)

S = spirituality (rated 0 - +++)

 

V

B

F

MS

T

FF

S

Cost

Healthyroads

 

 

2nd edition in press

 

 

 

 

 

Hemi-sync

F

Music

ocean

 

1A&B Preop

2A&B Intraop

3A&B Recovery

4A&B Recuperation

5A&B Energy walk

6A&B Ocean only
 

++

Very D

0

 

0

(++

#5

only)

$69.00

Huddleston

F

Heartbeat

1A Preop

1B Preop without

heartbeat

0

Mostly D

+

+++

$  6.50

(Book

$9.75)

Naparstek

F

Music

1A Preop

1B Postop

2A&B Music only,

for intra or postop

+++

P

+++

++

$17.98

Neimark

M

Ocean

1A&B Pre, intra and

postop

+++

Mostly P

+++

0

$10.00

Rodgers

F

Music

1A&B Preop

2A&B Intraop

3A&B Postop

0

D/P

0

0

(+ #3

only)

$30.00

Tusek

F

Music

1A&B Pre or Postop

2A&B Music only,

for intra or postop

0

P

+++

++

$17.00

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Top]

Detailed information on commercial tapes

 

Healthyroads
“Guided Imagery Program: Preparing for Surgery

Voice

 

Background

 

Format

 

Medical
suggestions

 

Tone

 

Family and

Friends

 

Spirituality

 

Cost

 

Comments

 

Contact

2nd edition in press

 

 

 

 

 




 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hemi-sync
“Surgical Support Series”

Voice

Background

Music and tones; #5 has ocean also, #6 is only ocean

Format

1A&B - Preop
2A&B - Intraop
3A&B - Recovery (recovery room)
4A&B - Recuperation (when in pain or unable to sleep)
5A&B - Energy walk (guided imagery of going to the beach, being able to walk easily and strongly, and receiving energy from the water, grass, sky, etc.)
6A&B - Ocean sounds only

Medical suggestions

Generalized for body system "balance and equalization", plus some suggestions for pain control and sleep.

Tone

Very directive 

Family and Friends

Spirituality

0  (++ in tape #5 only)

Cost

$69.99 [However, if you are having surgery for endometriosis, and are a member, you can get discounted tapes for $45 through the Endometriosis Association www.endometriosisassn.org]

Comments

This is the most overtly hypnotic of all the tapes reviewed, with extensive directive language, extremely slow pacing, abundant repetition, counting down on every tape, and the use of “encodings”, or post hypnotic suggestions for relaxation, pain relief and sleep.  The first tape has a twenty-minute progressive muscle relaxation, and the rest of #1-4 is direct suggestions.  #5 is a more traditional guided imagery, and #6 is relaxing ocean sounds with no talking.  These tapes are 45 minutes a side, longer than most other preop tapes.  The Hemi-sync appellation comes from differential sounds in the headphones to theoretically “synchronize” both sides of the brain.  The company has a warning against epileptics using these tapes.

Contact

Hemi Sync
 P.O. Box
 Lovingston, VA  22949
(434) 263-8692
www.toolsforwellness.com (a distributor)

 

Huddleston, Peggy
“Prepare for Surgery, Heal Faster”

Voice F
Background Heartbeat
Format 1A Preop with heartbeat
1B Preop without heartbeat
Medical Sugg. 0
Tone Mostly directive
Family and
Friends
+
Spirituality +++
Cost $6.50 for tape and $9.50 for book, when bought through website
Comments This tape does not work well without reading the book, or at least attending one of the Huddleston preop preparation programs organized at various hospitals.  On the plus side, the book is excellent, and highly recommended for anyone facing surgery.  On the tape, after a hypnotic-type relaxation with counting down and progressive muscle relaxation, the patient is instructed to go to an ideal place, recognize the light of higher self flowing through their body, remember a loving relationship, visualize themselves recovered, and imagine healing another area of their life.  There is minimal helpful description at these points, which is why reading the book is necessary. Other differences of this tape program than the others:
1) Listening to the tape is to be done when awake only.
2) There is a system of written statements that patients are supposed to have their surgeons and/or anesthesiologists read to them in the operating room.  Although this can be helpful, studies have more consistently shown that suggestions work if they are given preop rather than intraop.  (See Research – Hospital).  If you decide to use this program, you might want to read the medical suggestions to yourself each time you listen to the tape preop.
3) Instructions are for each of these statements to be repeated by your surgeon five times.  There does not appear to be research supporting this practice, and your surgeon might be more amenable to participating if they simply read the statements once.
4) You will need to get a music tape to listen to in the operating room.
5) This program has the most spiritual emphasis of those reviewed.
Contact

Angel River Press
Box 1038
Cambridge, MA  02140-0009
(617) 497-9431
www.healfaster.com

 

Naparstek, Belleruth

“Surgery”

Voice F
Background Music
Format 1A Preop imagery
1B Postop affirmations
2A&B Music only, for Intra or Postop
Medical
suggestions
+++
Tone P
Family and
Friends
+++
Spirituality ++
Cost $17.98
Comments Well-known tape set that covers all the appropriate medical and imagery bases as well as all the necessary hospital time periods.  After relaxing with the breath and going to a personal place, the patient is introduced in a non-threatening way to a screen through which they see themselves in the operating room.  There they are surrounded by capable professionals and loving family, and imagine via medical suggestions the ideal outcome.  Postop there are affirmations to speed emotional and physical healing. The second tape in the set is music only, for listening to in the operating room.  This tape has been chosen by Blue Shield for their surgical program, and has shown significant positive results in two clinical trials.  It is being used in hundreds of hospitals.
Contact

Image Paths, Inc.

P.O. Box 5714

Cleveland, OH  944101-0714

(800) 800-8661

www.healthjourneys.com
 

 

Neimark, Neil MD

“Less Stress Surgery”

Voice M
Background Ocean
Format 1A&B can be used for Pre, Intra and Postop
Medical
suggestions
+++
Tone Mostly P
Family and
Friends
+++
Spirituality 0
Cost $10.00
Comments This tape intersperses relaxing beach imagery with support of friends and family, and didactic information about the several medical suggestions that are given.  It can be used during any time period. The unique combination of male voice and more factual information than most other preop tapes, might make this tape more appealing to certain patients.
Contact

R.E.P. Technologies

14822 Elm Ave.

Irvine, CA  92606

(949) 451-6060
www.mindbodymed.com
 

 

Rodgers, Linda

“P.I.P. Surgical Audiotapes Series”

Voice F
Background Music
Format 1A&B Preop
2A&B Intraop
3A&B Postop
Medical
suggestions
0 (+ #3 only)
Tone D/P
Family and
Friends
0
Spirituality 0
Cost $30.00
Comments Using a combination of directive and permissive language, after progressive muscle relaxation the patient goes to an island beach and then a personal place, repeated throughout the three tapes with variations for circumstances.  Since there are no preop medical suggestions included, you may want to copy down those listed under Make your own tape, and repeat them to yourself each time you use this tape preop.  The postop tape is unique in actually covering the recovery room experience in detail, guiding you as you wake up, explaining various sensations you might have due to tubes, etc., and using imagery to feel better.  The set comes with a handy container to hang from an IV pole.
Contact

Audio Prescriptives Foundation

70 Maple Ave.

Katonah, NY  10536

(914) 232-6405
 

 

Tusek, Diane

“Guided Imagery for Stressful Times”

Voice F
Background Music
Format 1A&B Pre or Postop
2A&B Music only, for Intra or Postop
Medical
suggestions
0
Tone P
Family and
Friends
+++
Spirituality ++
Cost $17.00
Comments This tape focuses more on “stressful times” and doesn’t mention surgery whatsoever.  It therefore can be used for just general stress reduction, and might also serve as an adjunct to another surgical prep tape, especially if you get tired of listening to just one.  If you want to avoid the whole issue of surgery, this is the tape for you.  But if not, since there are no medical suggestions included, again, you may want to copy the suggestions from Make your own tape and repeat them to yourself when you use this tape preop.  On the tape, after focusing on breathing, going to a personal place and receiving the support of loved ones, side A directs you to go to a beach where the surf can cleanse away worries, and side B to a meadow where your problems are floated away on a hot air balloon. This tape has shown significant positive results in one clinical trial.
Contact

Guided Imagery, Inc.

2937 Lamplight Lane

Willoughby Hills, OH  44094

(440) 944-9292 

www.guidedimageryinc.com
 

 

[Top]

Make your own tape
Please see What design parameters should I consider? and decide on what overall approach would work best for you.  Pick who will be the main voice, and who might be chiming in; get your equipment organized (30 minute/side tape works best), arrange background sounds if you are going to utilize this option (music, ocean, nature), write your script and have a rehearsal. Use your creativity to provide the images you need. How are you feeling about the surgery?  Scared?  What could you imagine that would make you unscared?  Below are some general suggestions, but there are many variations, and you might have some unique requirements.  Follow your intuition.

Generic tape:
1)  Establish a relaxed state with a method you already use, or focus on breathing, or relax one part of your body progressively at a time.
2)  Go someplace else—somewhere you’ve been, would like to go, or completely in your imagination.  Somewhere in nature that is beautiful and serene is often used.  Describe it in detail with all of your senses, emphasizing how safe and good you feel there. 

If you’d like, you can make the above last about twenty minutes, do a continuous loop on both sides of the tape and stop there.  Or…

Other elements to possibly add to a generic tape:
3)  Family, friends, pets.  Who would you like to meet there?  (Living or deceased.)  Have them show their love, support and protection in some way via whatever image comes to mind—all holding hands, hugs, them talking to you, etc.--or have them actually talk to you on the tape.
4)  Spirituality.  Would you like to interact with a religious figure, be bathed in a light from the sky, feel connected to nature, or feel a protective presence?  What would this presence offer you or say, and how would it make you feel?

Again, if you’d like you can stop here.  The tape you’ve created from #1-4 could be used preop, intraop and postop, to decrease anxiety and provide you with inner support.  However, to get the maximum benefit from using a surgical preparation tape, medical suggestions could also be utilized.

Choose from an array of medical suggestions to add to your preop tape:
5)  Trust in the professionalism and skill of your doctor and the hospital staff.
6)  Decrease nausea and vomiting – usually this is couched in positive terms by saying that when you wake up after surgery you will feel hungry for _____ (your favorite food), and/or that you will notice activity and gurgling in your abdomen.
7)  Decrease in pain – positively say that you will feel comfortable and relaxed, feeling little discomfort and able to cope with how you feel.  Imagine the muscles around the incision releasing tension and being relaxed and comfortable.  Avoid using the word pain.
8)  Decrease in bleeding – suggest to yourself that you will have minimal bleeding, that the blood flow can move away from the area of surgery so that the doctors can see better, and then return with nutrients to increase healing when the time is appropriate.
9)  Several other functions can be mentioned, depending on what is pertinent to your situation—urinating easily, breathing easily, etc. 
10) If you are in a complicated situation, and know you are going to wake up with various tubes, or especially on a respirator, develop some words and imagery that help you work together with your equipment as a team; that the tube is your friend, aiding you until you can act on your own.
11) Suggest that if something unusual happens during surgery, all of your body systems can easily coordinate to compensate and adjust for your maximum benefit.
12) Remark on how beautifully and quickly your incision will heal.
13)  Imagine moving freely and easily in the hospital after surgery.
14)  Imagine some future time after surgery, when you are completely healed, and doing some favorite activity with ease.
15)  Thank your body for its amazing ability to heal.

Intraop and to a certain extent postop you could use this tape #1-15, and/or listen to music.

*********************

Best wishes as you embark on this taping project,
as well as for a speedy recovery to full health.

*********************

 

   
Previous       Top       Next
Questions?  Dr. Stein       Comments?  Webmaster
100 W. El Camino Real, Suite 65, Mtn. View, CA 94040
(650) 559-9597
© Harise Stein, MD 2002-2006